ReviewsDominican

Fuente Hemingway Short Story: Small but Serious

Reviewed cigar

Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story

Brand
Arturo Fuente
Line
Hemingway
Vitola
Short Story
Wrapper
Cameroon
Binder
Dominican
Filler
Dominican
Size
4.0 inches × 49 ring
Strength
Medium
Origin
Dominican Republic
Price
$8–13
Smoking Time
45 min

July 29, 2026

By Marcus Hale

Last updated: July 29, 2026

93
Construction
88
Draw
91
Flavor
92
Burn
90
Value
91
Overall / 100

Who should buy

  • Smokers who want real flavor in a 45-minute window
  • Anyone stepping up to Cameroon wrappers from mild sticks
  • Value hunters who overlook the small size

Who should skip

  • Dedicated full-bodied smokers wanting power
  • Beginners who will rush the tricky perfecto light
  • Anyone unwilling to pay above MSRP when shops mark it up

A four-inch cigar that punches like a full-size one

The Hemingway Short Story landed in 1983 as Carlos Fuente Sr.'s tribute to Ernest Hemingway, the smallest vitola in a line built to echo the Cuban perfectos of the 1950s. It is a Cameroon wrapper over Dominican guts in a stubby, double-tapered four-by-forty-nine format. I weigh what a cigar gives you for the money, and this one has been a benchmark small smoke for decades because it delivers grown-up complexity in a size you can finish on a coffee break.

The flavor is the whole argument. Sweet cedar, sugar cookie, roasted nut and a polite pepper, all fine-grained and balanced rather than big. The construction is classic Fuente - dead-straight burn, firm ash, cool smoke - with the single caveat that the closed perfecto foot is fussy to light and will trip up a beginner who hurries it. Take your time with the toast and it rewards you.

Value is where it gets interesting. At an MSRP around eight to ten dollars this is an easy recommendation, but the Cameroon wrapper is chronically short in supply, so plenty of shops charge above sticker and you may pay a small premium to find them. Even so, it holds up. If you want the same Cameroon-over-Dominican character in a bigger, slightly richer format, the Fuente Don Carlos Robusto runs around thirteen and smokes more polished. Want more Nicaraguan body in a small premium stick? Look at a petit Oliva Serie V. But as a small perfecto that overdelivers, the Short Story sits in a class of its own.

Where it fits is easy: this is the cigar for the forty-five-minute window - a morning coffee, a walk, a break between things - when you want real flavor and do not have an hour and a half. It is also a fine gateway to Cameroon wrappers for someone stepping up from mild sticks. Just budget the patience to light it, and grab a few when you see them in stock.

Pre-light & Cold Draw

Four inches, tapered at both ends, wrapped in a Cameroon leaf the color of milk chocolate with a faint tooth to it. The perfecto shape makes it look like a scale model of a bigger cigar. Cold, it smelled of cedar and sweet hay, and the draw pulled a little snug through that closed foot - expected with this format. Firm all the way down, no give, the kind of roll Fuente is known for. For eight or nine bucks it feels like more cigar than the size suggests.

First Third

Getting the pointed foot lit takes a slow, patient toast - rush it and you fight the burn all the way. Once it caught, the first puffs were sweet cedar and a light sugar-cookie note that is pure Cameroon, with a pepper tingle sitting behind it. Nothing loud. The Short Story trades power for finesse and tells you so in the first inch. The draw loosened up nicely past the taper, and the smoke came cool and fine-grained.

Second Third

Roasted almond crept in through the middle, still riding that sweet-wood base, the pepper fading to a background hum. This is the stretch where the little cigar shows why people keep boxes of them around - there is real layering here, not just one flat note stretched across four inches. My burn line stayed sharp without a single correction, the pale ash clinging in firm chunks. For the size, the smoke output is generous.

Final Third

The last stretch picked up a light cocoa edge and a touch more spine, though it never crossed into full. Across about forty-five minutes it stayed civil to the nub, no bitterness creeping in as the tiny cigar heated up - which is the real test of a small format. Some full-bodied smokers will find it too gentle for their taste. I read it as a medium cigar doing exactly what it means to do, and doing it cleanly.

Pros

  • Full-size complexity - sweet cedar, nut, cocoa - in a four-inch cigar
  • Classic Fuente construction: straight burn, firm ash, cool smoke
  • Reasonable MSRP around $8-10 for the flavor on offer

Cons

  • Closed perfecto foot is tricky to light for beginners
  • Chronic supply shortages often push street prices above MSRP
  • Medium body may read too gentle for dedicated full-bodied smokers

Frequently asked questions

Is a four-inch cigar really worth it?
It smokes like a much bigger cigar, that is the whole point. You get sweet cedar, roasted nut and a little cocoa with real layering, not one flat note stretched thin. For a coffee-break smoke it overdelivers.
Is it hard to light?
The closed perfecto foot is fussy and will trip up a beginner who hurries it. Give it a slow, patient toast and the draw opens up nicely past the taper. Rush it and you will fight the burn the whole way.
Why does it cost more than the $8-10 MSRP sometimes?
The Cameroon wrapper is chronically short in supply, so plenty of shops charge above sticker. You may pay a small premium just to find them in stock. Even so, I think it holds up at the higher street price.
How does it compare to the Don Carlos Robusto?
Same Cameroon-over-Dominican character, but the Don Carlos is bigger, runs around thirteen, and smokes more polished. The Short Story is the one for when you only have 45 minutes. I keep both around for different windows.
Is it too mild for me?
If you live on full-bodied sticks, it may read gentle - it is a clean medium doing exactly what it means to. It never turns bitter as the little cigar heats up, which is the real test. But strength chasers should look elsewhere.

Community tasting notes

No community notes yet. Be the first to share how this smoked for you.

Log in to share your tasting notes and photos.