A four-inch cigar that punches like a full-size one
The Hemingway Short Story landed in 1983 as Carlos Fuente Sr.'s tribute to Ernest Hemingway, the smallest vitola in a line built to echo the Cuban perfectos of the 1950s. It is a Cameroon wrapper over Dominican guts in a stubby, double-tapered four-by-forty-nine format. I weigh what a cigar gives you for the money, and this one has been a benchmark small smoke for decades because it delivers grown-up complexity in a size you can finish on a coffee break.
The flavor is the whole argument. Sweet cedar, sugar cookie, roasted nut and a polite pepper, all fine-grained and balanced rather than big. The construction is classic Fuente - dead-straight burn, firm ash, cool smoke - with the single caveat that the closed perfecto foot is fussy to light and will trip up a beginner who hurries it. Take your time with the toast and it rewards you.
Value is where it gets interesting. At an MSRP around eight to ten dollars this is an easy recommendation, but the Cameroon wrapper is chronically short in supply, so plenty of shops charge above sticker and you may pay a small premium to find them. Even so, it holds up. If you want the same Cameroon-over-Dominican character in a bigger, slightly richer format, the Fuente Don Carlos Robusto runs around thirteen and smokes more polished. Want more Nicaraguan body in a small premium stick? Look at a petit Oliva Serie V. But as a small perfecto that overdelivers, the Short Story sits in a class of its own.
Where it fits is easy: this is the cigar for the forty-five-minute window - a morning coffee, a walk, a break between things - when you want real flavor and do not have an hour and a half. It is also a fine gateway to Cameroon wrappers for someone stepping up from mild sticks. Just budget the patience to light it, and grab a few when you see them in stock.
Community tasting notes
No community notes yet. Be the first to share how this smoked for you.
Log in to share your tasting notes and photos.