ReviewsNicaraguan

My Father No. 3 Crema Review

Reviewed cigar

My Father No. 3 Crema

Brand
My Father
Vitola
No. 3 Crema
Wrapper
Ecuadorian Habano Rosado
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Size
6 inches × 49 ring
Strength
Full
Origin
Nicaragua
Price
$10–14
Smoking Time
75 min

August 23, 2026

By Marcus Hale

Last updated: August 23, 2026

95
Construction
94
Draw
93
Flavor
94
Burn
90
Value
93
Overall / 100

Who should buy

  • Experienced smokers who want elegance over brawn
  • Fans of slender formats and creamy, cedary texture
  • Anyone wanting a slow, contemplative flagship smoke

Who should skip

  • Beginners and mild-palate smokers
  • Anyone who wants maximum power and body
  • Fast puffers - the slim ring can sharpen

The flagship blend stretched long and elegant

The My Father No. 3 Crema is a full-bodied 6 by 49 corona gorda - Ecuadorian Habano Rosado wrapper over Nicaraguan binder and filler, with the family's signature pigtail cap. It's the long, slender size of the original 2008 flagship line, the same blend as the No. 1 and No. 2 but in a narrower, more elegant format. It smokes cocoa, cedar, black pepper and a creamy texture, delivering the flagship character in its most refined, nuanced form over about seventy-five minutes.

What the slender format changes is texture and pace. The narrower 49 ring gives a higher wrapper-to-filler ratio, which brings out more cedar and the creamy character that earns the 'crema' name, while the longer six inches smoke cooler and more slowly than the fatter No. 1 Robusto or No. 5 Toro. The result is the flagship blend leaning elegant rather than brawny - still full and cocoa-forward, but more nuanced, the pepper softened by a creamy cedar edge. Construction is classic My Father: oily wrapper, an excellent draw through the slim body, straight burn, tight ash.

My reservations are about pace and palate. It's still a genuinely full cigar despite the elegance - not a mild smoke - and the slender 49 ring warms up and can sharpen if you puff too fast, so it rewards a slow, patient cadence. If you want more power and body, the fatter No. 1 or No. 5 deliver it; if you want the shortest format, the No. 1 is the pick. For the flagship blend at its most refined and creamy, though, savored slowly, this is the one.

Where it fits is the contemplative smoke for an experienced smoker who wants elegance over brawn - the flagship My Father at its most nuanced, a size to savor with coffee or a fine spirit rather than power through. It pairs beautifully with an unhurried moment. As the elegant corona gorda of the original line, it's the connoisseur's size.

Pre-light & Cold Draw

The No. 3 Crema is the long, slender size of My Father's original flagship - a 6 by 49 corona gorda, the most elegant format in the line. Same 2008 blend as the No. 1 and No. 2, but the narrower ring and longer length change how it smokes. Ecuadorian Habano Rosado wrapper, Nicaraguan guts, the family pigtail cap. The wrapper is oily, rosado-brown, the slim shape refined in hand. My cold draw pulled cocoa and a creamy cedar. This is the flagship stretched long - more elegant, a touch creamier than the fatter sizes.

First Third

It opens full but refined - the narrower 49 ring concentrates the wrapper against the filler, so the pepper arrives with a creamy cedar edge rather than the No. 1's broader spice. The longer corona gorda format smokes cooler and more slowly, letting the cocoa-and-cream character lead. The pigtail clipped clean, draw excellent through the slimmer body, burn a straight line. Where the fatter sizes emphasize power, the No. 3 leans elegant. A refined, creamy-spiced start.

Second Third

The middle is where the slender format pays off. The higher wrapper-to-filler ratio of the 49 ring gives more cedar and a creamier texture - the 'crema' name earns itself here - while the cocoa-leather core stays full underneath. It runs cool and slow over the long six inches, more nuanced and less brawny than the No. 1 Robusto. My ash held a tight column, burn immaculate. This is the flagship blend at its most elegant and refined, the size for savoring rather than powering through.

Final Third

The final third deepens cocoa, cedar, pepper and cream over roughly seventy-five minutes total, full but elegant to the nub. My verdict: the No. 3 Crema is the flagship My Father stretched long and refined - the connoisseur's elegant size. Honest notes: it's still a full cigar, and the slender 49 ring warms up if you puff too fast. But for the flagship blend at its most nuanced and creamy, smoked slowly, this is a beautiful size.

Pros

  • The flagship blend at its most elegant and creamy
  • Slender ring brings out cedar and a refined texture
  • Cool, slow-burning, excellent draw

Cons

  • Still genuinely full - not a mild smoke
  • Slender ring warms up if you puff too fast
  • Less power and body than the fatter No. 1 or No. 5

Frequently asked questions

Why is it called the Crema?
The narrower 49 ring gives a higher wrapper-to-filler ratio that brings out a creamier texture and more cedar than the fatter sizes - the 'crema' name reflects that smoother, creamier character. It's the same flagship blend, just expressed more elegantly in a slender format.
How is it different from the No. 1 Robusto?
Same blend, different proportions. The No. 3 Crema is longer and slimmer (6 x 49), smoking cooler, slower and creamier with more cedar; the No. 1 Robusto (5.25 x 52) is more balanced and slightly brawnier. Pick the No. 3 for elegance, the No. 1 for everyday balance.
Is a slender cigar still full-bodied?
Yes - the No. 3 is genuinely full, just more refined and creamy than the fatter sizes rather than milder. The slender ring changes the texture and nuance, not the strength. It's best for an experienced palate smoked slowly.
How should I smoke it?
Slowly - the slender 49 ring heats up and can sharpen if you puff too fast, which spoils the creamy elegance. A patient, unhurried cadence keeps it cool and lets the cedar-and-cream character shine over its seventy-five minutes.
What should I pair with it?
Coffee complements the cocoa and cream; a smoother spirit like aged rum or a lighter whiskey suits its elegance better than something too aggressive. It's a contemplative size, so pair it with something you can savor slowly.

Community tasting notes

No community notes yet. Be the first to share how this smoked for you.

Log in to share your tasting notes and photos.