ReviewsNicaraguan

My Father Cedros Eminentes Review

Reviewed cigar

My Father Cedros Eminentes

Brand
My Father
Vitola
Cedros Eminentes
Wrapper
Ecuadorian Habano Rosado
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Size
5.625 inches × 46 ring
Strength
Full
Origin
Nicaragua
Price
$10–14
Smoking Time
70 min

August 24, 2026

By Marcus Hale

Last updated: August 24, 2026

95
Construction
93
Draw
93
Flavor
94
Burn
90
Value
93
Overall / 100

Who should buy

  • Experienced smokers who love cedar in a cigar
  • Fans of slim, elegant, aromatic formats
  • Anyone wanting a distinctive twist on the flagship blend

Who should skip

  • Beginners and mild-palate smokers
  • Anyone who wants maximum power and body
  • Those who dislike a cedar-forward profile

The flagship blend with an extra layer of cedar

The My Father Cedros Eminentes is a full-bodied 5.625 by 46 corona - Ecuadorian Habano Rosado wrapper over Nicaraguan binder and filler, sheathed in a thin Spanish cedar sleeve you peel off before lighting, finished with the family's pigtail cap. It's the cedar-sleeved size of the original 2008 flagship line, the same blend as the numbered vitolas but with an aromatic cedar signature no other size carries. It smokes cocoa, cedar, black pepper and leather in the flagship's most woody, elegant form over about seventy minutes.

What sets the Cedros apart is that cedar character, and it comes from two places at once. The Spanish cedar sleeve leaves its sweet, aromatic mark on the wrapper, and the slim 46 ring - the narrowest in the line - gives a higher wrapper-to-filler ratio that brings out even more cedar and elegance. The result is the flagship pepper-and-cocoa blend wrapped in the most woody, aromatic profile the line offers, cool and refined over the corona format. Underneath, it's the same full, rich classic. Construction is classic My Father: oily wrapper under the sleeve, excellent draw, straight burn, tight ash.

My reservations are format and handling. It's still a genuinely full cigar - not a mild smoke - and the slim 46 ring warms up and can sharpen if you puff too fast, so it rewards patience. And the cedar sleeve is meant to be peeled off before lighting, not smoked through, so don't skip that step. If you want more power and body, the fatter No. 1 or No. 5; if you don't care for cedar, the No. 1 leads with more balanced spice. For the flagship blend with the most cedar character, though, this is the distinctive one.

Where it fits is the aromatic, elegant smoke for an experienced smoker who loves cedar in a cigar - the flagship My Father at its most woody and refined, a size to savor slowly. It pairs beautifully with coffee or a smooth spirit. As the cedar-sleeved corona of the original line, it's a distinctive twist on the flagship.

Pre-light & Cold Draw

The Cedros Eminentes is the cedar-sleeved size of My Father's original flagship - a 5.625 by 46 corona, wrapped in a thin sheet of Spanish cedar that you peel off before lighting. Same 2008 blend, but the cedar sleeve adds a marker no other size in the line has. Ecuadorian Habano Rosado wrapper underneath, Nicaraguan guts, the family pigtail cap. Slide off the cedar and the wrapper is oily and rosado-dark. My cold draw pulled cocoa laced with sweet cedar from the sleeve. This is the flagship with an extra layer of cedar character.

First Third

It opens full with the cedar note amplified - the Spanish cedar sleeve leaves its aromatic mark, so the flagship pepper and cocoa arrive wrapped in a sweet, woody cedar edge cleaner than any other size. The slim 46 ring is the narrowest in the line, concentrating the wrapper for an elegant, cedary start. The pigtail clipped clean, draw excellent through the slender body, burn straight. Where the fatter sizes lead with power, the Cedros leads with wood and spice. A refined, cedar-forward start.

Second Third

The middle is the flagship blend threaded with extra cedar. The cocoa-leather core stays full underneath, the pepper present, but the cedar - both from the sleeve and the slim ring's higher wrapper ratio - gives this the most aromatic, woody profile of the original line. It runs cool over the corona format, elegant and nuanced like the No. 3 Crema but with a distinct cedar signature. My ash held tight, burn immaculate. This is the flagship for someone who loves cedar in their cigar.

Final Third

The final third deepens cocoa, cedar, pepper and leather over roughly seventy minutes, full but aromatic to the nub. My verdict: the Cedros Eminentes is the flagship My Father with an extra layer of cedar - the aromatic, woody size of the line. Honest notes: it's still full, the slim 46 ring warms if you rush, and the cedar sleeve is a peel-off you shouldn't smoke through. But for the flagship blend with the most cedar character, this is a distinctive, elegant size.

Pros

  • The flagship blend with a distinctive extra cedar character
  • Slim ring and cedar sleeve give an aromatic, elegant profile
  • Cool, refined burn with an excellent draw

Cons

  • Still genuinely full - not a mild smoke
  • Slim 46 ring warms up if you rush
  • Cedar sleeve must be peeled off - don't smoke through it

Frequently asked questions

What's the cedar sleeve for?
The Cedros Eminentes is sheathed in a thin sheet of Spanish cedar that imparts a sweet, aromatic cedar note to the wrapper during storage. You peel it off before lighting - it's not meant to be smoked through - and it's what gives this size its distinctive extra cedar character.
How is it different from the No. 3 Crema?
Both are slim, elegant sizes of the same flagship blend, but the Cedros Eminentes (5.625 x 46) adds the cedar sleeve for a more aromatic, woody profile, while the No. 3 Crema (6 x 49) leans creamier. The Cedros is the one to pick specifically for cedar character.
Is it still full-bodied?
Yes - underneath the cedar it's the same full flagship blend, cocoa-forward and peppery. The slim ring and cedar sleeve make it more aromatic and elegant, not milder. It's best for an experienced palate smoked slowly.
How should I smoke it?
Peel off the cedar sleeve first, then smoke slowly - the slim 46 ring heats up if you puff too fast, which sharpens it. A patient cadence keeps it cool and lets the aromatic cedar-and-cocoa character shine over its seventy minutes.
What should I pair with it?
Coffee complements the cocoa, and a smooth spirit like aged rum or a lighter whiskey suits the elegant, cedary profile. The aromatic character rewards attention, so pair it with something you can sip slowly and savor.

Community tasting notes

No community notes yet. Be the first to share how this smoked for you.

Log in to share your tasting notes and photos.